If not quite as remarkable as the band's gripping
self-titled debut, What's THIS For...! showed that Killing Joke could maintain
their frenetic, doom-wracked intensity while experimenting with their already
strongly established style. Jaz Coleman's vocals go through even more
treatments and tweaks than before, chorus shout-alongs swathed in deep echoes,
hidden behind Geordie Walker's punishing riffs and the steroid-driven rhythm
section. Big Paul Ferguson in particular lays down some absolutely skull-crushing
drum slams and Youth is no less intense at most parts, and often they rather
than Coleman or Geordie dictate the song, as the lengthy death-groove of
"Madness" makes perfectly clear. Elsewhere Geordie shows a calmer
(comparatively) side, soloing on songs like "Butcher" making common
cause with the guitar work of Bernard Sumner in Joy Division days -- indeed,
the song as a whole could almost be a tribute to that band, and one of the
better ones at that. The playing around with supposed genre boundaries doesn't
hurt either -- the beatbox/synth loop pulse of "Follow the Leaders,"
crossed with the more brusque blasts from the core band, suggests its eventual
path in later years, while "Tension" lets the slithering funk heart
of the band burst forth even more strongly. (The drums and opening riffs
themselves almost sound like a parody of the Knack's "My Sharona.")
"Unspeakable" is arguably the hidden highlight of the album,
Coleman's heavily flanged, distorted singing sliding down a slowly descending
chord pattern that suggests an early glam band gone martial and paranoid,
Ferguson all over his set like four people at once. The debts of later bands
toward Killing Joke are even clearer than ever, whether it's the fact a group
named themselves after the opening track, "The Fall of Because," or
that late-'80s Ministry so effectively cloned the whole style on songs like
"Burning Inside."
Ripped from the expanded CD to MP3 @ 320kbps
Killing Joke; What’s THIS For…!
1. The
Fall Of Because
2. Tension
3. Unspeakable
4. Butcher
5. Follow
The Leaders
6. Madness
7. Who
Told You How?
8. Exit
9. Follow
The Leaders (Dub)
10. Madness
(Dub)
11. Brilliant

Always has felt something of a damp squib after the first LP. Great opening and then slowly but surely my interest wanes. Will give the digital version a whirl this morning. Thanks :) David
ReplyDeleteIt has become an acquired taste. A classic in it's own right, with highs and lows as many albums have, showing the way towards The Hum
DeleteI always thought this was one of the rare sophomore albums that was even better than the extraordinary debut. I love Unspeakable and Madness.
ReplyDeleteI'd never say that "What's..." is better that the debut but it is still a classic
Delete