While their full-length albums Echelons and December established them as kings of midwestern melodic gloom, In The Marshes stands as the absolute darkest, rawest, and most experimental chapter in For Against's history. Originally recorded primarily on a humble 4-track cassette recorder in 1986 during a brief hiatus from the Echelons recording sessions, these six songs were shelved for years before being rescued from the vaults. Master printer Bruce Licher eventually resurrected the tracks in October 1990, releasing them as a stunning, hand-numbered letterpress 10" mini-album for Independent Project Records' archival series.
Stepping away from the polished, propulsive dream-pop rhythms that would define their later catalogue, this record captures the trio—Jeffrey Runnings, Harry Dingman III, and Greg Hill—plunging headfirst into an uncompromising, esoteric post-punk abyss. The sessions found the band actively breaking their own rules, substituting live percussion with manually triggered electronic drum pads, cranking up the reverb units, and letting their British post-punk influences mutate into a harsher, more discordant beast. It stands as a brilliant, claustrophobic document of a band operating at their most unvarnished and daringly experimental edge.



















